Johnny Maestro (May 7, 1939 – March 24, 2010) was the
lead singer of one of the first mixed-race vocal groups to achieve
success in the US charts. The Crests — a group that consisted of three singers of Afro-American descent, a Puerto Rican and Maestro, who was of Italian parentage — reached No 2 in the US pop charts in February 1959 with 16 Candles, a doo-wop-styled ballad that has remained a staple of oldie radio stations and pop
reissue albums since its release.
success in the US charts. The Crests — a group that consisted of three singers of Afro-American descent, a Puerto Rican and Maestro, who was of Italian parentage — reached No 2 in the US pop charts in February 1959 with 16 Candles, a doo-wop-styled ballad that has remained a staple of oldie radio stations and pop

Maestro went on to form the Brooklyn Bridge in the
late-1960s, an 11-strong vocal group whose name was acquired when a friend said
that with so many people in the band they had as much chance of success as they
had of selling the Brooklyn Bridge. Despite that forecast the group went on to
have a No 3 hit in 1969 with a cover of the Fifth Dimension song The Worst That
Could Happen. The group has remained a recording and touring act up to the
present day.
![]() |
The Crests' lineup in the late 1950s featured (from left)
Patricia Van Dross, Johnny Maestro, Harold Torres, Talmadge (Tommy) Gough and
J.L. Carter.
|
Maestro was born John Mastrangelo in 1939 in New York City and grew up on the Lower East Side of Manhattan. He met the other members of the group at the Henry Street Settlement, a non-profit-making social services centre in Manhattan. The group decided on the name the Crests and practised, like many other groups of their time, in tenement hallways, on the streets and in the New York subway system. One day, while harmonising on a train, they were approached by a woman who gave them her business card. She turned out to be the wife of the musician and arranger Al Browne, who gave the group a chance to cut two tracks for the tiny Joyce label in Brooklyn. "My Juanita"/"Sweetest One" became a regional hit.
In 1959 the group joined a slightly larger record label,
Coed, and were rewarded with the biggest hit of their career, 16 Candles, a
ballad written originally as 21 Candles, but later modified to attract a
younger, teenage audience. Other hits followed including "Six
Nights A
Week", "Step by Step", "The Angels Listened In", and
"Trouble in Paradise".

Between "Step by Step" and "Trouble in
Paradise", Coed released a single "The Great
Physician"/"Say It Isn't So" under the name Johnny Masters. Late
in 1960, Maestro would leave The Crests for a solo career. Maestro was unable
to reach his former chart heights with The Crests, but did have Top 40 hits
with "What A Surprise" and "Model Girl" in 1961 as solo
artist Johnny Maestro
, "The Voice of the Crests" for Coed Records. For
his next three singles with the label, he was known as Johnny Maestro, the
third spelling change for the label. None of those records charted and
Maestro
recorded for three different labels before recording with new backup singers
(none from the original group) as Johnny Maestro & The Crests in 1965 and
1966, which produced four singles on two more labels.

Maestro left the group in the early Sixties and
re-emerged a few years later as lead singer with the Del-Satins, the group
which had backed the New York singer Dion DiMucci on his solo hits. Entering a
talent contest they were pitted against a group called the Rhythm Method. The
groups met after the show and agreed to join forces, creating the 11-strong
Brooklyn Bridge.
Johnny and the Bridge rehearsed their unusual combination
of
smooth vocal harmonies and full horns, and signed a recording contract with
Buddah records. Their first release, a version of the Jimmy Webb song
"Worst That Could Happen", reached No. 3 on the Billboard pop chart.
It sold over one and a quarter million copies, and was awarded a gold disc. The
follow-up, "Welcome Me Love", and its flip side, "Blessed is the
Rain" — both by Tony Romeo each reached the Top 50. The group sold over 10
million records by 1972, including LP sales, mostly produced by Wes Farrell.
Appearances on The Ed Sullivan Show, The Della Reese Show, and other programs
helped to bring the group to the national stage.

The group appeared in the film version of the musical
Hair (1979) and enjoyed a string of well-received releases. When their
recording activities tailed off in the 1980s the group continued to perform live
to great acclaim.

After its heyday, the Brooklyn Bridge downsized to a
five-man group, with the vocalists playing their own instruments. For example,
Maestro could be seen on stage playing rhythm guitar, while former Rhythm
Method bassist Jim Rosica picked up a vocal part. Later in the 1970s, as the
Rock and Roll Revival evolved from a nostalgic fad to a respected genre, the
group began to add members, retaining its core vocalists. By 1985, the group
had solidified into an eight piece group, including original Del Satins,
Cauchi, Fred Ferrara, and original Bridge member Rosica, augmented by a horn
section for special occasions.
Maestro’s last performance with the group was in January
when the Brooklyn Bridge were among groups appearing in Connecticut at a
concert billed as The Ultimate Doo-Wop Party. He died, after a long battle with
cancer, on March 24, 2010, aged 70. (Info edited from Times Online & Wikipedia)